“Today, in our field, there is so much talent and recognition that we are reaching a saturation point. An artist should no longer strive only for breathtaking craftsmanship; he should, instead, try to help us live better, either by dressing the wounds that are constantly being opened by society, or by offering solutions to get us out of the mess we’re in…But it’s going to be difficult and we have a lot of work to do.” - Jean 'Moebius' Giraud

Friday, October 05, 2007

IM: ETM#2_reviews


I've got nothing new for today except for this little ditty I drew after I got an email from an enthusiastic fan that had a bunch of compiled reviews from both ETM #1 and #2. Very nice of your, sir. Much appreciated.

But my masochistic side thought, "Well, they can't all be positive, right? Let's try to find some of the ones that aren't as high on the praise, shall we?"

And thus was born the first few entries of today's blog. While I appreciate the rest of the reviews which are genuinely wholly positive, enthusiastic, etc...one of my personal favorites is the one where the guy said I can't draw feet to save my life. Which has been a personal shame of mine since forever and have lost several lives over the fact. I've just never been called out on it before. Oh, thank you sir, for airing my dirty little secret so now I may try to live my non-feet drawing life without such a hidden shame. Thank you!

Seriously though - thanks to all that have said such tremendously kind words about the book thus far, either through message boards (which I've only recently become privy to - there's that much talk over comics and how they don't fit into continuity? Geez, people...c'mon!) or via direct e-mails to me. You are all awesome in my book. BTW, the project has only been as great as it has been because of the great people associated with it. Much love and KUDOS to Joe Casey, Dave Stewart, Thomas Brennan, and Stephen Wacker These guys are a riot to work for.

BTW, Iron Man: Enter the Mandarin #2 came out today. Please go pick it up and watch the Golden Avenger duke it out with a really mongoloid looking Mandarin. I'd certainly appreciate the support.

Okay, here are those reviews:

-------------------------------------------------------------

(http://forum.newsarama.com/showthread.php?t=113253)


JoeK32880


The Mandarin is by far my least favorite character in all of comics and Eric Canete will always be the crappy artist who took over Mr. Majestic after McGuiness left.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

(http://www.allaboutcomics.com/blog/?p=116)


Iron Man: Enter: The Mandarin #1 (of 6)

Writer: Joe Casey; Artist: Eric Canete


By Phil Mateer

Marvel, obviously, would like a few stand-alone trades ready for the movie, ones that don’t need explanations involving the words “S.H.I.E.L.D” or “Civil War,” and it’s logical to have one with the Mandarin’s origin. Casey is good at this retro-continuity stuff; Tony’s in the Avengers, and everyone still thinks Iron Man is his bodyguard, but the electronics are reasonably current, and the timeline is within the last ten years or so (the Mandarin’s still a Chinese warlord who boosted his rings off of an alien spaceship in the 1950s). Competent, and it moves along well enough, but the art is better at the page design and tech than it is at actual figure drawing (for example: Canete can’t draw feet to save his life — look at the book’s final panel), and I’ve already read versions of this origin a couple of times before, so it’s easy to pass on this one.
--------------------------------------------------------------------

(http://www.silverbulletcomicbooks.com/reviews/118920025568197.htm)


Iron Man: Enter the Mandarin #1


Posted: Friday, September 7
B

y: Kevin Powers


Writer: Joe Casey
Artist: Eric Canete Published by: Marvel Comics

The new Iron Man trailer will be debuting in a few days and as anyone who saw the ComicCon footage knows, this movie has he potential to be Marvel’s best. I personally can’t wait. With Marvel in full creative control of the film, the possibilities are endless, not to mention Sam Jackson will be Nick Fury. There is one aspect of this film that has left me completely baffled. While Obadiah Stone/Iron-Monger seems like a very plausible villain, I’m surprised that there hasn’t been much speculation or wonder about the Mandarin. I’ll be interested to see how this plays out, especially with this week’s release of Iron Man: Enter the Mandarin. I know that the main Iron Man book is gearing up for the Mandarin’s big return, but this series, as well as the main series, will feature the Mandarin coinciding with the film’s release in February. While director Jon Favreau has stated the characters presence will be felt, I hope it is done so in a manner that makes any possible sequel a “can’t miss.”
Iron Man: Enter the Mandarin is a unique way to introduce readers to the power and the influence of the Mandarin. For younger readers it is especially so because the style of artwork resembles that anime-style kids’ love. Honestly, one of the things to really grab me was the cover art. The cover is fantastic, reminiscent of pulp heroes and an older 40’s style of work. The cover also shares a resemblance to one of the finer “modern pulp” films of my generation, The Rocketeer. Nonetheless, this style of cover looks quite fantastic. Joe Casey does something with this story I really didn’t expect. To be honest, I didn’t expect a whole lot from this issue other than a re-telling of the Mandarin’s origin and Iron Man’s first meeting with him. Casey goes a different route; the Mandarin already exists and S.H.I.E.L.D. has recruited Iron Man to investigate the villain’s influence in China. It seems simple enough but Casey makes the wise choice in setting this tale in a more modern environment. There’s e-mail, modern spy equipment, and a B-2 Stealth Bomber. This works well not only for younger readers, but for regular Shell Head fans as the story is given the feeling that it’s happened in the past twenty years and can be utilized in the modern Iron Man stories. This story is and isn’t something special. It’s not special in the fact that it doesn’t seem like it will break any new ground in terms of Iron Man and the Mandarin. But this title is very special in that it takes the classic iterations of both characters and pits them against one another for the “first time.” The Mandarin is going through some physical changes in the main Iron Man series, and to see the classic version of the character in action is really fun. The dialogue he spits also fits true to the character, exerting his power over the communist regime in China. Casey manages to show both a reasonable and overly-aggressive character in the Mandarin that fits well with the character’s ancestral ties to Genghis Khan. I am not the biggest fan of the artwork in this issue. A lot of that comes from my distaste for the anime-style being in American comics. I’m not a fan at all of manga and that can often sway my opinions on certain matters. While the style here isn’t completely manga, it’s just not my cup of tea. I will say though, that the Mandarin looks fantastic in his classic robe. While this story may not be completely mind-blowing, it’s a whole lot of fun. It’s got the potential to be entertaining and exciting and that’s really all one can ask for from a series pitting two classic arch-enemies against one another. I hope Casey can keep the exciting and energetic tone that this issue established, as I feel this series will definitely be a fun experience.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------

(http://www.comixtreme.com/forums/showthread.php?t=36902)


IRON MAN: ENTER THE MANDARIN #2 ADVANCE REVIEW


Review by: Blake M. Petit Blake@comixtreme.com

Quick Rating: Good

Rating: A

Iron Man faces the Mandarin in their first battle!

Writer: Joe Casey Pencils: Eric Canete Colors: Dave Stewart Letters: Comicraft Editor: Stephen Wacker Cover Art: Eric Canete Publisher: Marvel Comics

Joe Casey’s career path seems to have lead him to a comfortable niche in the past, telling stories of the early years of various Marvel characters, and Enter: The Mandarin is proving to be a quite worthy addition to that line-up. This issue, Iron Man meets his arch-foe, the Mandarin, for the first time, and the battle doesn’t necessarily go the Golden Avenger’s way. The story isn’t bad (although, like I mentioned last month, I still question the real need for a Mandarin miniseries), but for me, the artwork is the real selling point. I really like Canete’s work – beautiful, fluid and full of energy. He has a distinct retro feel, but whenever he brings in modern elements like Tony’s high-tech lab, or even the series of e-mails he trades with Pepper Potts, it doesn’t feel out of place. While it’s unlikely that anyone but serious Iron Man fans (if there are any left) will pick up this miniseries, it’s a fun little book that’s worth looking at for anyone who enjoys a book with a nice Silver Age/early Bronze Age feel to it, and particularly satisfying for those of us unhappy with the way Tony’s being portrayed in the modern comics these days.
----------------------------------------------------------

(http://2guysbuyingcomics.blogspot.com/2007_09_01_archive.html)


IRON MAN: ENTER THE MANDARIN #1


Joe Casey writes, Eric Canete draws, and while I'm not sure what the point is (which, sadly, is a feeling I get with most of Casey's Marvel work) , it's charming in its own way.
Basically updating the Mandarin's origin story, but in a way that we don't even see most of it (!), this shows Iron Man being asked to investigate some mysterious new power broker in China (guess who), Mandarin telling the Chinese government that he's more powerful than they are (and that takes waaaaaaay too long), and IM and Mandy getting ready to throw down by issue's end. I mentioned early on that it's charming, right? That's due almost entirely to Eric Canete's artwork, which is so different from your standard superhero fare that it reminds me more of something you'd see in Mad Magazine, believe it or not (and I'm thinking of a specific MAD artist, but damned if I can remember his name). And I think it works beautifully, really setting itself apart style-wise. Best Moment: Seeing Tony, Happy, Pepper and company interacting like we're used to seeing them, back in the day. This is definitely old-school. Worst Moment: That whole pissing match between Mandy and the Chinese generals could have (and probably should have) been done in one page. Comic Book Goodness: 3/5. Interested to see how they're getting 6 issues out of this, I love the artwork, and it's old-school Iron Man. Yeah, I'm on board.
--------------------------------------------------

(http://comics.ign.com/articles/824/824658p1.html)


Iron Man: Enter the Mandarin #2 Review

Iron Man and his archenemy throw down old-school style.
by Jesse Schedeen Comics like Iron Man: Enter the Mandarin exist for a reason. Comics were comparatively silly back in the day. Any character who was introduced longer than 20 years ago probably came onto the scene with a frantic one-page introduction sequence full of arcane dialog. Modern comics are useful as a means of going back and re-exploring these origin stories in greater depth and with more mature sensibilities. The Fantastic Four didn't just spring to life while a gaggle of well-groomed children stood around licking over-sized lollipops and saying, "Gee, mister. That rocky skin of yours sure is swell!" Joe Casey understands this. Last year he revamped the FF's origin with Fantastic Four: First Family, and this year he's doing the same to the Mandarin. Of all the many Marvel villains, the Mandarin is perhaps most in need of a revamp. For me, the character has dangerously skirted the line between credible counterpoint to Tony Stark and poorly realized caricature. I like what the Knaufs have been doing with Mandarin in the ongoing Iron Man series, but it doesn't really change what's come before. Casey's Mandarin is a man who discovered great power in the form of an alien spaceship, and now some fifty years later has become a major force in Chinese politics. It's not political intrigue on the level of something like Checkmate, but it's a darn sight better than having Mandarin twirl his mustache and threaten to blow up 20 orphanages if the U.S. government doesn't pay him one billion dollars. Interestingly, Casey downplays the dynamic of good versus evil. Despite his sinister overtones, Mandarin doesn't exactly instigate the conflict with Iron Man. Instead, Stark agrees to be part of a covert military operation that goes awry. This issue showcases the first real fight between the two. Yes, even in this day and age, superheroes and villains often solve their difference with fist fights. One thing to notice during the many pages of fight scenes is Eric Canete's art. The cartoony, bombastic pencils are about as far as you an get from the very realistic tone of the Iron Man ongoing, but they aren't a bad fit for this comic. Despite its mission to modernize a classic Marvel story, this comic is very much a throwback to the "good old days." If a post-Civil War Tony Stark rubs you the wrong way, this comic will give you a glimpse of Iron Man before his armor got all tarnished.

RATING: 8.1 out of 10
------------------------------------------------

(http://www.earth-2.net/reviews/c/iiwy/iiwy-013)


Iron Man: Enter the Mandarin #2
Writer: Joe Casey Artist: Eric Canete Colorist: Dave Stewart Letterer: Comicraft Cover: Eric Canete

Review: Tim Glancy


Last week, while reviewing Iron Man #22, I went on somewhat of a rant about Iron Man's place in the current Marvel Universe. In short, I was rather frustrated that he went from being a pretty fun, but flawed, character, to a supremely powerful character that never loses a fight. This was exceptionally hard for me to take, because I was, and am, a pretty large Iron Man fan. I see the need to involve Iron Man in a lot of books and all over the line right now, because there is a huge movie coming out next May starring the Golden Avenger. And, unlike Spider-Man and the X-Men who were huge worldwide long before their movies, Iron Man is of a lower profile, so he could really use the exposure he's been receiving over the last two-ish years.
However, it seems that Marvel may have realized they are alienating a certain percentage of Iron Man fans. First there was Marvel Adventures Iron Man which harkened back to Iron Man's old, tech-based adventures. The drama and continuity might be missing, but it's really a fun book with lots of action. And now, with Enter the Mandarin, Marvel has reached back into the character's history and is allowing us to revisit the never before seen first battle between Iron Man and his greatest villain, the Mandarin. Joe Casey handles the writing chores here, and does a tremendous job of taking a story that we can all assume the outcome of and makes it feel exciting and fresh. Casey has long been a favorite of mine, especially his runs on The Adventures of Superman and G.I. Joe: America's Elite. Casey has a great way of humanizing characters, even Superman, and he does a great job of that here as well. We get to see Tony Stark get his ass kicked and we see how he deals with that, which is something that you would not see nowadays. Casey breathes life not only into Stark, but also Mandarin and another longtime Iron Man villain (who will remain nameless to not spoil the book for anyone). He also gives us an interesting reason to care about these characters. Mandarin, like all good villains, is only evil because of his methods, not because of his intentions. And Casey really puts that on display here, fleshing out a character who's often referred to as "that guy with all the rings." From the plot to the pacing to the dialog, every bit of writing is handled tremendously well. The art, while different from what you will see in any other superhero book, is just spectacular. There is really an old school feeling in the rough look, but an overall polish that makes the art standout from the rest of the pack. Eric Canete is someone who I had never even heard of before this book, but rest assured that I will be looking for more of his work in the future. His style is just so unique and attention-grabbing. He handles every aspect well, from the action to the details and even to the cover (which is tremendous). He really needs to have his worked seen and spotlighted. I hope that Canete continues to work with Dave Stewart on colors, because the colors really compliment the art. As a whole, this book is just a fun romp and a pretty good story as well. The only negative that I can think of is the lack of long-term effects that will come out of this book. Therefore, I have to give two recommendations. If you are in a place where buying one more book won't kill your financial standing, then please buy this book, because it is just so damn fun. However, if you are in the same boat I am in and your comic buying is severely limited, please borrow this from a friend. After reading it, you just might drop another comic for this one.

25 comments:

Phil said...

Whoever wrote the comment about you being that crappy artist that took over Majestic is simply wrong... and not knowing anatomy? I personally dig your anatomy, and think that you tweak things in a very intersting and non-mainstream way; so much more refreshing than all the hackish stuff that pretty much comprises all of comics. It's sickening how fickle 'fans' are, and how ready they are to degrade people for the most miniscule things. Comics as an industry and community seem soooo scared to move from the stagnate pool that they are in. Sorry about dropping the rant on your blog, I just can't believe people are ripping into you about this. I haven't read the books yet, but they'll pobably be the first comics that I've bought in over two years. I'm glad you are producing work, keep it up Eric!

Adam said...

I just picked up both issues this week and love'em! I've been watching your blog for awhile now and i love how frequently you post compared to other artists, so thanks for that. Yeah, don't let feet hater get you down. Where's his Marvel miniseries? If he's buying comics for accurate feet,I think he needs to be reading Bridgeman's or Villpu. Keep up the great work man.

Guillermo P. Mogorrón said...

Making Critics is alright, but people lacks some respect for artists who spend part of their lifes trying to improve their drawing and storytelling skills.
In a fair world everyone could say what they think and everyone would be talented, but sadly we not live there, talent is not equally shared, but criticism yes.

clem said...

Some critics need to learn that no matter how loud you yell from the bleachers, it doesn't make you part of the game.

William Dean Blankenship Jr. said...

Already have #2. To hell with Mcguiness. Too bubbly. I'm going to have to find those back issues of Majestic.

Your easily becoming a favorite. Your stuff is a feast for quality-starved eyes.

3!LL

Brian said...

Just read issues 1 and 2 and really enjoyed both the story and the art.

I really liked your "classic hollywood leading man" take on Tony, and your versions of Pepper and Hap were spot on. The Mandarin comes across as a real challenge to Iron Man and I love the version of the armor that you are using.

Really looking forward to the next 4 issues.

ryan cody said...

The best compliment I think one can get is that you are an "artist's artist", and I don't know any professionals out there that don't completely love your stuff Eric.

Lauren said...

Your feet look fine to me. Now if you want to talk about everything else, I'm gonna need a lot more writing room. ;)

Skotti said...

God, I love your art more and more every day. You've been a huge influence on me since I first saw your work in Cybernary 2.0.

I don't give a crap what the geeks say about Enter the Mandarin, I'm still loving your work.

fabio said...

DOn`t worry man, you're great, whoever wrote that is just a frustrated artist that lives in a basement from his parent's house. I'm a comic book artist myself and you are a inspiration, your work is just great. Keep working the way you are!

Rodrigo said...

im sorry if it bothers you, but i downloaded the comic, the first two, i live in chile and cant buy them when they come out, so i have to wait for spanish versions... but if it makes you feel better, this one im gonna pick it up surely when its on the stores down here. loved the artwork and style.

keep it like that, because its looking awesome

potato farm girl said...

Feet are really hard to draw.

Neil Hill said...

This series of reviews only further cements you as a favorite of mine, Eric, because you're willing to see the good/bad/ugly and embrace all three.

As an artist- we who are often so cowardly when it comes to dissenting opinions about our work- I can completely empathize with why you might run and hide from some of these reviews, but you don't. Instead you choose to be the hero and face them- heck, not just face them but post them!! Kudos to you for that.

Also, these reviews prove that thankfully true Iron Man fans are looking at this series critically rather than just drooling over the artwork like me. In face, I wouldn't be much use in trying to parse the details of whether events fall into proper Iron Man continuity or not, because frankly I don't care. I'm a Canete fan and that's why I like the series. But anyway...

ANX said...

That was a really heavy but entertaining read man. And I'll admit that Majestic was the first thing I'd seen from you. I was a little displaced because it was a big shock of a difference between the two styles.

But after I'd read through your Majestic issues I was clawing for more. I'm just glad I found you at SDCC one year and picked up your really thick design book with the airborne robot design work. Deeply fell in love with your work since then.

gdeo said...

hey eric....love the second issue...your stuff gets better and better and dave's colors make you art just "POP"...just to let you know...my 9yr old loves your art also..keep up the great job.

alberto said...

I'll make mine brief and to the point. You rock!

alberto said...

Hmm, I just wrote a comment but it didn't take.
Anyway, it was simple and straight to the point.
You're artwork rocks.

John Beatty said...

Good stuff...I don't really like Iron Man...but you've made him "hip" to look at!

Lot's of energy in the pages and layouts, as usual...your style is original and dynamic!

Keep on going and doing what you do...

-JBeatty

Toyebot said...

your stuff is some of the most refreshing work I've seen in a long time! Great vibe to it! Can't please everyone but you're pleasing most!
cheers

Mark said...

Eric, your art is fantastic, and I dont think some jerk who probably cant draw a straight line has the right to criticize someone who has worked in the industry professionally for numerous years.

"zomg, he cant draw feet!" What a clown.

Your awesome Eric, dont ever think different. That's an order.

Nexxorcist said...

Hey eric, you forgot to draw the feet in that lil panel up there. haha. good work on the book man.

brunopags said...

dude, i am sooooo tired of "profesional" critics, i read a few of those negative reviews + they hav no idea what their talking abt. as an art student you're one of my fav artists 2 look at 4 anatomy and technique(the others being bruce timm, ashley wood, james jean and pierre allery) dont let the bastards tear u down, thats all they know how 2 do. thankyou 4 all the inspiration over the years as well as the hours of great reading :)

Adriana said...

those people can suck it, seriously. that crap about your anatomy is bs, these are people that have been brainwashed to think that all guys are over cross-hatched huge refrigerator shaped tanks and all girls are scary giant boobed things with giant hair. they see something different from the norm and think it's "anime" (them vomting at anything that can be remotely construed as anime is just thinly veiled xenophobia crap). the fact that they can't distinguish your art from anime and that they don't know that your feet are AMAZING, proves you shouldn't take anything they say seriously. don't let the mouth-breather basement dwellers get you down.

arnie said...

to add to the prasie, i only picked up Mr Majestic, "BECAUSE" McGuiness left.

peace out

Cheeks said...

Hey, Eric. Man.....I had no doubt I'd be blown away by the beauty you brought to the Ironman books. I wait eagerly for your 3rd issue. I can't get enough of your art. It oozes with spark, energy, and wisdom. Keep leading the way, sensei.